On the N.W. point of Prince Edward Island, a light would be highly useful to vessels who crossing the Gulf are forced down in the bight by violent N.E. winds. The rapidly increasing trade of Miramichi and the many rising settlements in the Strait of Northumberland, would also well justify the erection of a Lighthouse there.
A decade later, in 1851, the House of Assembly called upon the Lieutenant Governor to “enter into communications with the several Governments of Canada, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland, and with the Imperial Government, both as respects themselves and the United States, with the view of ascertaining what proportion they will contribute to the expense of establishing Light Houses at the North Cape and East Point of this Island: as such establishments, at those places, would be of greater utility to the shipping interests of the Countries referred to, than to the similar interests of this Colony.”
Nova Scotia did send a reply saying that Prince Edward Island had failed to pay money promised for the construction and maintenance of lighthouses in its colony, so they were disinclined to contribute.
In 1860, the Lieutenant Governor of Prince Edward Island again sent a letter to the Lieutenant Governors of the North American Provinces requesting support for lighthouses at North Cape and East Point, noting that many vessels belonging to the adjoining colonies had wrecked on these headlands in the last few years. As the principal harbours of Prince Edward Island traded primarily with points southward, the Lieutenant Governor again noted that the establishment of the lights was of much more importance to “strangers” than to the vessels of Prince Edward Island.
Frustrated by the futile attempts to obtain a lighthouse for North Cape, David Petrie placed a light on the edge of the cape in 1861. The following year, a petition was presented to the House praying for a small grant to remunerate Petrie for his work, noting that the “present depressed state of Commerce and Finance” could not justify the erection of a proper lighthouse.
A £190 contract for the construction of a keeper’s cottage and a fence of cedar for the grounds of the North Cape Lighthouse was given to John Chiasson in early 1866.
A year after Prince Edward Island entered Confederation, the General Superintendent of Lighthouses visited the North Cape Lighthouse in 1874 and called it “one of the most important light stations on the Island.” The illuminating apparatus at that time was a fourth-order lens, but the light was deemed “not of the power and character that its importance demands.” The following year, this problem was corrected when a powerful revolving white light on the catoptric principle was installed and placed in operation on July 1, 1875. The light produced a single flash every minute, and the new lantern, revolving apparatus, lamps, and reflectors cost $2,339.42.
In 1945, it was noted that the North Cape Lighthouse and dwelling needed to be moved back from the edge of the nearby cliff, which had seriously eroded in recent years. Four years later, the move had not occurred, and by that time the dwelling was unfit for habitation. When winds were on shore during cold weather, sea spray would freeze on the dwelling creating a heavy coating of slush and ice. At times, this ice buildup sealed the keeper inside the dwelling, forcing him to chop his way out.
A new dwelling was constructed for the keeper in 1950, and the tower, a woodshed, and the old dwelling, relegated to serve as a storage shed, were moved roughly 122 metres (400 feet) inland in 1951 by Neil McDonald and D. O’Leary at a cost of $4,785.
North Cape Lighthouse was automated in 1967, and the following year the 1950 dwelling and two sheds were sold off as surplus. Though the tower is not open to the public, tourists are still drawn to North Cape, where they can walk out on the reef at low tide, marvel at the wind turbines at the Atlantic Wind Test Site, or visit the gift shop, restaurant, and aquarium in the North Cape Interpretive Center.
Tignish Initiatives submitted a petition for ownership of the lighthouse under the Parks Canada Heritage Lighthouse Program. On September 25, 2013, North Cape Lighthouse was awarded a Provincial Designated Heritage Place plaque and certificate.
Keepers: Stanislaus F. Perry (1866 – 1872), Patrick Hogan (1872 – 1873), J. Stanislaus F. Perry (1873 – 1876), Lewis McDonald (1876 – 1877), Peter H. Perry (1877 – 1883), Augustin Hackett (1883 – 1897), James Phee (1897 – 1912), Dougal P. McCarthy (1912 – 1928), James Mark Gaudet (1928 – 1931), Leo J. Shea (1931 – 1939), Wilfred Brennan (1939 – 1940), Percy Patrick Morrissey (1940 – 1956), Basil W. Spears (1956 – at least 1966).
Photo Gallery: 1