In late September 1855, Major Hartman Bache, who served as the engineer and inspector of west coast lighthouse from 1855 to 1859, issued the following report on Point Pinos Lighthouse, after having sailed past it both during the day and at night:
I regret to say the result of this cursory examination was entirely unfavorable to the point now occupied. It answers neither the condition of a coast light or a harbor light as fully as it might. ...The light is soon lost sight of in approaching Monterey, due in great measure to the interposition of trees, the light having been built just at the edge of, if not within, the woods. Whenever I have the means, by a proper survey, of determining the space from which the trees should be cut to give full effect to the light throughout the entire arc of visibility called for by the position and elevation, I will have them removed.Bache felt the lighthouse should have been built closer to the shore, and he made a drawing to illustrate how Monterey Pines practically surrounded the lighthouse.
After the lighthouse had been in operation a few years, certain parties, who claimed to be the owners of the land on which it was built, “restored to vexatious proceedings” in an attempt to coerce the government into paying $8,000 for the site. The courts ruled in the claimants’ favor, and a jury awarded the landowners $1,280. Unsatisfied with this amount, Thomas R. Hopkins and the other claimants appealed the decision, and Congress was forced to pay $6,000 in 1879 to cover damages and legal services.
In 1880, an enclosed porch was added to the east side of the lighthouse to serve as a storehouse and to protect the entrance to the dwelling’s kitchen. Three years later, mineral-oil lamps replaced the lard-oil lamps used inside the Fresnel lens. Water for the occupants of the lighthouse was obtained by capturing the rainfall from the roof and storing it in a 10,000-gallon cistern. In dry years, the supply was often inadequate and had to be supplemented by water hauled in at a considerable expense. In 1885, a pipe system, nearly a mile in length, was run from the lighthouse to tap into the Pacific Improvement Company’s water supply.
Two of the more noted lighthouse keepers at Point Pinos were women. After being appointed the first keeper of Point Pinos Lighthouse, Charles Layton moved his family into the small dwelling on the point. Just a few months later, Keeper Layton, who had been a soldier in Florida for many years, was shot while riding with a posse in pursuit of the bandit Anastacio Garcia. Layton soon died from his wound, leaving his wife Charlotte to look after the light. The local customs official wrote to the Lighthouse Board recommending Charlotte be appointed the next keeper:
By this dispensation of providence, his widow, Charlotte A. Layton and four children have been left entirely destitute. I authorized her to continue at the post occupied by her late husband, and she is now discharging all the duties of principal keeper of the Lights at Point Pinos. I take much pleasure in recommending her for the position: she is industrious and bears an unblemished reputation.Charlotte served as head keeper of the lighthouse until 1860, when George Harris, her second husband, became keeper of the light.
Fifty-year-old Emily Fish, accompanied by her Chinese servant Que, succeeded Luce as keeper of Point Pinos Lighthouse in 1893. When sixteen, Emily had traveled to China to visit her sister and brother-in-law, and during this overseas sojourn, Emily’s sister died while giving birth to a baby girl, later named Juliet. Emily married her brother-in-law and raised Juliet. Later in life, after returning to the states, it was Juliet’s husband who, while serving as a lighthouse inspector, notified Emily of the opening at Point Pinos. Emily, whose husband had passed away before her appointment, was known as a meticulous keeper and as a congenial host to numerous guests who visited her at the light. Her fondness for entertaining led to her being called the Socialite Keeper.
Several newspapers carried a story in 1912 on the recognition Emily Fish received for her twenty years of service: “The only woman in the United States in full charge of a seacoast lighthouse is Mrs. E.A. Fish of Point Pinos, near Pacific Grove, Cal., who has lately received a letter of commendation for her twenty years faithful service from the chief of the lighthouse service, together with a medal bearing the inscription, “U.S.L.S.” and “Efficiency.” She has been in charge of the Point Pinos light since the death in 1892 of her husband, who was head of the department of history and physiology in the University of California.”
On April 18, 1906, during Emily Fish’s tenure, an earthquake shook Point Pinos Lighthouse. The station’s logbook for that date records, “At 5:13 AM violent and continued earthquake shocks jarred the lens causing it to bend the connecting tube and loosened the lens so it was movable – also enlarged the crack in the trim and coping. The jarring of the dampers caused the flame to run up.” It took two days before news of the devastating destruction in San Francisco, which was closer to the epicenter, reached the lighthouse.
The brick tower suffered extensive damage in the earthquake, and after the lantern room and lens were removed, the upper five feet of the tower were torn down and rebuilt using reinforced concrete. A lens lantern was displayed from atop a temporary structure erected at the north end of the lighthouse for a few nights followed by the station’s Fresnel lens, while the tower was rebuilt.
The harbor of Monterey is a regular port of call for coasting steamers operating between San Francisco and Los Angeles. It is also the shipping port for large quantities of crude oil, and some of the largest oil carriers on the coast enter this port regularly. The harbor is also the headquarters of upward of 2,000 large fishing boats. Heavy fogs are frequent at this part of the coast, and at present there is no protection for vessels entering the harbor. Numerous applications have been received from shipowners and shipmasters for the establishment of a fog signal at the light station, and there is a very urgent need for its establishment as soon as practicable. The combined dwelling and tower at this station was built in 1855 and is only sufficient to house the present keeper. An additional dwelling is needed.When finally established on the point 1,600 feet northwest of the lighthouse in May 1925, the fog signal sounded a double blast every thirty seconds. Modern residences for the keepers were built on the lighthouse property in 1939 and 1959.
Point Pinos Lighthouse was automated in 1975 and licensed to the City of Pacific Grove, which opened the lighthouse through its Pacific Grove Natural History Museum. The Adobe Chapter of the Questers was very helpful in restoring the lighthouse and furnishing it with period pieces. The homey environment makes it easy to picture Emily Fish hosting a graceful evening at the lighthouse for her guests, which included artists, writers, and naval officers.
Asphalt floor tiles have been removed and the original Douglas fir floors have been refinished. In 1998, the original eclipser, a metal panel that for several years revolved around the light source producing a twenty seconds on, ten seconds off signature, was restored and placed on exhibit in the basement of the lighthouse.
Point Pinos Lighthouse and nearly seventy acres of surrounding land were transferred from the Coast Guard to the city of Pacific Grove in August 2006. The Coast Guard will keep the two housing units on the property for key personnel and maintain responsibility for the beacon itself.