Nine-mile-long Conanicut Island separates Narragansett Bay into a west passage and an east passage, both of which have plenty of obstacles. Masters of the great steamers that ran between Providence, Rhode Island and New York City in the late 1800s pleaded for a fog signal near Plum Beach Shoal for many years. During heavy fog, captains trying to avoid Dutch Island, which lies off the west shore of Conanicut Island, would steer too far west and end up running aground on Plum Beach Shoal or other obstructions. Such was the case of the steamer Pequot, which went aground in June 1892 on Bonnet Rock while trying to avoid Dutch Island during a thick fog.

Plum Beach Lighthouse in 1903 Photograph courtesy National Archives

After repeated appeals from the Lighthouse Board, Congress finally approved the construction of a lighthouse and fog signal at Plum Beach on March 2, 1895. The estimated cost of the project was $60,000, and Congress provided $20,000 in 1895 and $40,000 in 1896.

I.H. Hathaway Company of Philadelphia, the selected contractor, began work on a wooden, thirty-five-foot-square, and ten-foot-tall caisson for the foundation on July 13, 1896 and finished it just over a month later. The caisson was launched on August 19 and two courses of the cast-iron foundation cylinder were placed atop it before it was placed at the site on the northern end of the shoal in seventeen feet of water on September 12, 1896. The last ironwork for the foundation cylinder was delivered on September 28, and on January 30, 1897 the eighth and final course was in place. To secure the foundation, 1,500 tons of riprap were placed around it.

The cast-iron foundation is one of thirteen that were built for lighthouses using a unique pneumatic construction technique. Prior to being put in place, the caisson foundation was equipped with a central access pipe, housing air supply and pressure tubes, a ladder, and a system to convey sand and muck up to the surface. Once the caisson had settled in place, water was pumped out from the square, air-tight chamber at the bottom. As debris was cleared out by workers in the pressurized compartment, the caisson slowly settled into the bay’s floor allowing additional sections of the foundation to be put in place.

As “unexpected difficulties” occurred during the laying of the foundation, it became clear that additional funds would be needed to finish the lighthouse. These “unexpected difficulties” included the discovery of a layer of quick sand just below the intended target depth for the foundation. As a result, the foundation had to be taken down an additional ten feet.

To mark the completed foundation, a temporary light was established atop a mast projecting above the cylinder on February 1, 1897, and a 1,028-pound fog bell, struck a double blow every thirty seconds, was added on June 1, 1897.

Postcard that appears to be based on the above image

After Congress allocated $9,000 on July 1, 1898 to complete the lighthouse, work resumed at the site with Toomey Brothers of Guilford, Connecticut being hired to erect the superstructure provided by Tacony Iron and Metal Company of Philadelphia. Poor weather caused more delays. During a blizzard in November 1898, the construction ship dragged anchor and headed down the west passage. Just when it looked as if the schooner and crew would either smash on rocks or be carried out to open sea, the anchor caught on a cable near Beavertail Lighthouse.

In a December 3, 1898 letter to the Lighthouse Board asking for a temporary halt to construction, the contractor wrote, “Plum beach, Narragansett Bay is the stormiest place we ever worked. It is either raining or blowing half the time.” Work ceased shortly thereafter and resumed in the spring. The lighthouse was finally completed in May 1899, and a fourth-order flashing light was established atop the structure on July 1, 1899. To provide a unique daymark for mariners, the lighthouse had a black foundation and lantern room, while the lower half of the superstructure was painted white and the upper half brown.

Joseph L. Eaton was appointed the first keeper of the lighthouse on June 5, 1897, and he served up until the lighthouse was commissioned on July 1, 1899, at which time Judson G. Allen was transferred from Whale Rock Lighthouse to take charge of the light.

Charles L. Ormsby served over twenty years at Plum Beach Lighthouse, longer than any other keeper. In October 1916, Keeper Ormsby returned from a shore furlough and found fifty-three-year-old John Boldt, his assistant, dead on the kitchen floor. Boldt, who had just been appointed assistant keeper in January of that year, apparently died of natural causes. Mariners reported that the light had burned less brightly than usual the night before Boldt was found dead, indicating that the light’s lamp had been unattended.

The winter of 1918, during which the entire bay froze over allowing automobiles to drive across the ice, proved to be a difficult one for Plum Beach Lighthouse. The shifting of the thick sheets of ice caused a one-inch crack that circled the entire lighthouse to develop two feet above the low tide level. Other vertical cracks extended below the water line. The construction bids received for the repairs were considered too high, and nothing was done for several years. Finally in 1922, the cracks were fixed, and an additional 9,000 tons or riprap were placed around the foundation for extra protection. The repairs held until 1938, when the Great New England Hurricane opened the old cracks, created new ones, and caused quite a bit of damage to the tower. Substitute Keeper Edwin Babcock and Assistant Keeper John Ganze were unable to get away from the station before the storm and had to ride out the hurricane in the tower. Waves as high as thirty-five feet tore open doors and flooded the building. In order to not be washed overboard, the two keepers retreated to the fourth level of the tower and tied themselves to the center pipe containing the weights that turned the lens. The lighthouse and its keepers managed to survive the storm, unlike Whale Rock Lighthouse five miles away, which was carried away with its keeper.

Plum Beach Lighthouse

When the Jamestown Bridge opened in 1940, Plum Beach Lighthouse became obsolete. The Coast Guard distinguished the light on May 1, 1941, and shortly thereafter asked for bids, “preferably from wreckers,” to remove the lighthouse within ninety days. No bids were received, and the station was abandoned shortly thereafter. A long period of neglect followed, during which windows and doors disappeared, the cast-iron rusted, and bird droppings piled up on all the decks.

During 1971 and 1972, a professor and graduate student from the University of Rhode Island visited the lighthouse every week or two to conduct research on pigeons. As the floor was covered with up to six-inches of disease-carrying guano, the visitors had to don masks and other protective gear. The researchers discovered that the pigeons had a “birth-control system” that led them to hatch roughly the same number of eggs each year. In the first year of observation, the pigeons abandoned about forty percent of their eggs to apparently compensate from the lack of predators at the lighthouse. During the second year, the scientists removed twenty percent of the eggs shortly after they were laid and found that the pigeons dramatically reduced their desertion level to compensate for the lost eggs.

The Coast Guard and the State of Rhode Island bickered over the lighthouse for years, with neither party wanting to assume responsibility for the structure. In 1984, James Osborn, who was paid to paint the lighthouse in 1973, filed a $500,000 lawsuit against the state to compensate for a rare disease called histoplasmosis he contracted from all the dried guano in the tower. The lawsuit went back and forth between Rhode Island’s Superior and Supreme Courts for years. In June 1998, the courts determined the state was the owner of the lighthouse, and three months later the state paid Osborn $42,000.

In 1988, a private company tried to buy the lighthouse and move it to a condominium complex in Quincy, Massachusetts, where it would be turned into a lighthouse history museum. When this plan became public, the Friends of Plum Beach Lighthouse was formed to retain the tower and preserve and restore it in place. Neither group, however, was able to move ahead with their plans as the question of ownership was still being debated in the courts.

With the ownership issue resolved, the state gave the title to the Friends of Plum Beach Lighthouse in 1999. The non-profit obtained $500,000 that same year under the Transportation Act for the 21st Century, and Newport Collaborative Architects visited the site in 2000 and estimated it would cost $955,000 to completely restore the tower, inside and out.

In 2003, restoration of just the exterior of the lighthouse was begun by Abcore Restoration Company. The first step was the removal of over 50 tons of guano left by feathered visitors over the years. The interior was fully cleaned and the outside painted and repaired. In December 2003, the station was relighted for the first time in sixty-two years, using a solar-powered beacon that flashes a white light every five seconds – the lighthouse’s original characteristic.

On April 18, 2006, the center span of the original Jamestown Bridge was demolished, after a new concrete bridge had been completed in 1991 to take its place. Members of the Friends of Plum Beach Lighthouse were justifiably happy knowing that their lighthouse had outlived the bridge that made it obsolete.

In October 2009, the Friends of Plum Beach Lighthouse received approval to offer license plates featuring an image of the lighthouse. Proceeds from the sale of the plates would be used to maintain lighthouse, but an initial order of 900 plates was required. The Friends were able to surpass the minimum order in just eight weeks of sales, and since then thousands more have been sold. Thanks to the license plate revenue, the lighthouse received a fresh coat of paint in 2010. In 2015, a new, brighter LED beacon was installed, along with solar-powered floodlights for the base of the lighthouse. Plum Beach Lighthouse was repainted and refurbished again in 2022. In 2024, a grant from a local charitable trust funded a new rotating LED beacon know as the “Bob & Peg Fulton Memorial Beacon” for the lantern room.

If you live in Rhode Island and would like to purchase a plate to help maintain the lighthouse, click here.

Keepers:

• Head: Joseph L. Eaton (1897 – 1899), Judson G. Allen (1899 – 1904), George Ehrhardt (1904 – 1911), George Troy (1911 – 1913), Charles L. Ormsby (1913 – 1935), Reuben W. Phillips (1935 – at least 1939).
• First Assistant: Arthur W. White (1899 – 1901), John D. Davies (1901), Andrew F. Smith (1901 – 1905), James Joseph Bryan (1905), James Edward Creed (1905 – 1907), Walter Coppage (1907), Reuben W. Phillips (1907 – 1908), George A. Brown (1908), J.H. Royle (1908), Alfred Nelson (1909), Arthur J. Baldwin (1910), Benjamin G. Barber (1910 – 1911), George Doige (1911 – 1912), James H. Bentley (1912 – 1913), John A. Miller (1913 – 1916), John H. Boldt (1916), Edward Grime (1916 – 1917), George M. Wright (1918), Dosty Robarge (1918 – at least 1929), Reuben W. Phillips (at least 1930 – 1935), John O. Ganze (1935 – 1941).

References

1. Annual Report of the Lighthouse Board, various years.
2. America’s Atlantic Coast Lighthouses, Kenneth Kochel, 1996.
3. Northeast Lights: Lighthouses and Lightships, Rhode Island to Cape May, New Jersey, Robert Bachand, 1989.

The lighthouse is best viewed from the water, but decent views can be had from the Jamestown Bridge or from the shore at either end of the bridge. Rhode Island Bay Cruises offers a 10 Lighthouses of Narragansett Bay cruise that passes Plum Beach Lighthouse. Save the Bay offers lighthouse cruises that pass the lighthouse.

The lighthouse is owned by Friends of Plum Beach Lighthouse. Tower closed.

Find the closest hotels to Plum Beach Lighthouse

Kraig writes:

An aerial view of Plum Beach Lighthouse can be seen in the movie "Dan in Real Life," when Dan is driving his three girls over the Jamestown Bridge to visit his parents at their home on Conanicut Island.