The first lighthouse on Medway Head was a combination dwelling and tower constructed in 1851 and shown in the historic photograph on this page. Note the dark rectangles on the dwelling that served as a daymark.
The first keeper of the lighthouse was I. K. Perry who served for just two years until Elson Perry took over in 1853. Elson Perry kept the light for thirty-nine years, ending his service in 1892.
Four different lighthouse have stood on Medway Head. The first combination dwelling and tower was replaced by a similar structure in 1927, but this new two-story dwelling had a hipped roof with a central octagonal lantern room. It was into this lighthouse that Keeper Douglas R. Smiley and his wife Muriel moved in 1959. The Smileys must have been surprised to find that the dwelling lacked inside plumbing and central heating.
Muriel Smiley recalls that on November 22, 1963, the day President John F. Kennedy was assassinated, carpenters and plumbers arrived to update the dwelling with modern facilities. On October 9, 1964, cement was poured for a new dwelling at the station, and the Smileys moved into this four-bedroom residence in February 1965.
The Smileys began their lighthouse career at Beaver Island, where they arrived in 1952 with four kids. Seven years later, when they left for Medway Head, they had eight children, and by the time their service was over, they had raised a total of fourteen children.
On April 10, 1966, Department of Transport workers installed a new fiberglass tower on a cement pad to replace the 1927 lighthouse. This circular tower was white with a red band around its middle and another one near its top.
The 1927 lighthouse was sold in 1980 to Alden Wamboldt of Massachusetts, who was required to remove the structure from the property. Fortunately, the lighthouse was moved just a short distance from its original site to a hill overlooking the station, allowing visitors to easily photograph two lights in one picture.
On April 19, 1983, the fiberglass tower was replaced by the present pepper-shaker tower, and three years later the station was de-staffed following the retirement of Douglas Smiley after twenty-eight years at Medway Head. Douglas Smiley passed away in 1988 at the age of sixty-four, but Muriel was still regaling people with the stories of her life at a lighthouse as late as 2007, when she shared her experiences with a gathering of over fifty members of the Liverpool Seniors’ Club.
Alden and Roberta Wambolt had a memorial sign installed on the current lighthouse to honor the keepers of Port Medway. It reads:
I thank God for the lighthouse I owe my life to Him King Jesus is the lighthouse And from the rocks of sin He has shown his light around me That I might clearly see If it wasn't for the lighthouse Where would this ship be?
Keepers of Port Medway Elson Perry 1850-1892 Israel Foster 1892-1908 Will Atkins 1908-1910 Jonas Whynot 1910-1934 Stan Hubley 1934-1956 Russell Hunick 1956-1959 Douglas Smiley 1959-1987
A ceremony held at the lighthouse on June 11, 2014 celebrated the transfer of the tower and property on which it stands to the Medway Head Lighthouse Society. Substantial repairs were made to the lighthouse in 2015.